Shalev Barel

    Thoughts on AI and Product Management

    Back to writings

    Balancing User Needs and AI Capabilities

    How to find the sweet spot between what users want and what AI can realistically deliver.

    Balancing User Needs and AI Capabilities

    Product managers often face a fundamental tension when building AI products: the gap between what users want and what AI can realistically deliver. This gap creates both challenges and opportunities.

    Understanding the Capability Gap

    Current AI systems excel at some tasks (pattern recognition, language processing) but struggle with others (causal reasoning, common sense). As a product manager, you need to:

  1. Develop a clear understanding of your AI's actual capabilities
  2. Map these capabilities against user needs and expectations
  3. Identify where the gaps create friction points in your product
  4. Strategies for Bridging the Gap

    Scope Thoughtfully

  5. Focus on problems where AI can deliver high value within current limitations
  6. Break complex problems into components, applying AI only where appropriate
  7. Consider hybrid approaches that combine AI with human expertise or rule-based systems
  8. Set Clear Expectations

  9. Communicate AI capabilities and limitations transparently
  10. Avoid anthropomorphizing your AI in ways that create unrealistic expectations
  11. Frame AI assistance as suggestions rather than definitive answers when appropriate
  12. Design for the Gap

  13. Create interfaces that make AI limitations part of the expected experience
  14. Provide clear feedback when the AI is uncertain or operating outside its reliable domain
  15. Build "AI+human" workflows that leverage the strengths of both
  16. Case Study: AI Writing Assistant

    Consider an AI writing assistant product. Users want it to produce perfect, publication-ready text that captures their exact intent and voice. Current AI can generate fluent text but may misunderstand specific requirements or produce factual errors.

    Instead of promising perfect output, successful products in this space:

  17. Position themselves as collaborative tools that enhance rather than replace human writing
  18. Provide options rather than single answers
  19. Make revision and refinement a core part of the experience
  20. Clearly indicate when facts need verification
  21. Allow easy customization and correction
  22. Finding Opportunities in Limitations

    Sometimes, working within AI limitations leads to unexpected product opportunities:

  23. Constraining the problem scope can create focused tools that solve specific problems exceptionally well
  24. Explicitly involving humans in the loop can create unique value propositions
  25. Designing specifically for AI uncertainty can lead to novel interaction patterns
  26. Moving Forward

    The capability gap isn't static. As AI technology advances, previously unviable product concepts become possible. Smart product managers:

  27. Stay current on AI research and capabilities
  28. Maintain a backlog of features that aren't quite viable yet
  29. Continuously reevaluate assumptions about what's possible
  30. Build product architectures that can incorporate new capabilities as they mature
  31. By thoughtfully navigating the space between user needs and AI capabilities, you can build products that deliver real value today while positioning for an even more capable future.

    Edit with